What does an accountant check before filing your Self Assessment?
By Dhruv Chadha, co-founder of Record OS · Sources checked 22 October 2026
An accountant preparing or reviewing your Self Assessment should consider whether the information is complete, how income and gains should be taxed, whether relevant expenses and reliefs apply, and whether the resulting return makes sense. You should understand significant assumptions and decisions before approving it.
The exact work depends on the service you have agreed to. A review of a return you prepared is different from having an accountant prepare it from your records. Neither should be confused with software checking that a form is ready to submit.
This guide explains the questions worth asking and the information worth looking for.
Software checks and accountant review do different jobs
A software check might flag a missing field, inconsistent totals or an entry HMRC will not accept. Those checks are useful. They do not necessarily establish which income source a payment belongs to, whether an expense qualifies, or whether important information was omitted.
An accountant brings judgement to those questions. But “accountant checked” still needs a definition: ask who does the work, what they review and which records they will need.
| Service | What to establish before buying |
|---|---|
| Software validation | Which errors it checks, and what you remain responsible for deciding. |
| Review of a return you prepared | Whether the reviewer checks underlying documents and tax treatment, or a narrower part of the return. |
| Accountant-prepared filing | What records you provide, who prepares and reviews, and how you approve the result. |
Preparation and review do not always involve two different people. If a second reviewer matters to you, ask explicitly. For help choosing between service types, see our guide to personal tax return software and services.
Five areas to discuss with your accountant
1. Whether the information tells the whole story
A return can add up correctly while leaving out something important. Your accountant needs to understand the relevant income, gains and changes in your circumstances, rather than simply process whichever documents arrive first.
Useful questions might concern a missing statement, a new rental property, a job change, share transactions or time spent abroad. For example, uploading a P60 does not tell an accountant whether you also received untaxed interest or sold investments.
Be clear about what you have not yet supplied. A document list and follow-up questions help, but you still need to disclose relevant facts. Ask how missing information and assumptions will be resolved before filing.
2. How the figures connect to your records
Where records are part of the agreed work, ask how they have informed the return. Does the pay figure agree with the relevant statement? Has tax already deducted been included? Has the same income appeared in more than one document?
If data is extracted automatically, someone still needs to consider whether it has been interpreted and used appropriately. A clear explanation should let you trace a significant figure back to the information behind it, without requiring you to redo the entire calculation.
3. Tax treatment, expenses and eligible reliefs
Entering the right amount in the wrong place can change the result. Depending on your circumstances, professional work may involve considering the nature of a payment, the relevant tax year, residence, or the conditions for a particular claim.
It is reasonable to ask which expenses and reliefs were considered, what was claimed, and whether any apparent claim was excluded. An accountant should not invent deductions or promise savings before understanding the facts. Sometimes the correct conclusion is that a suggested claim is unavailable.
Illustrative example: An eligible self-employed person might have a choice between deducting actual allowable expenses and using the trading allowance. A useful explanation would say which route was used and why. HMRC explains that the allowance can replace actual expenses, subject to eligibility and restrictions[2]
4. Significant assumptions and judgement calls
Some decisions depend on information you need to confirm: whether a statement is final, how a payment arose, or whether you incurred an expense personally or for the business.
Look for an explanation that identifies the assumption and tells you what to correct if it is wrong. “We have assumed this statement includes all transactions for the year; please confirm” gives you something concrete to check.
A small final tax bill does not prove that a return has been reviewed well. The reasoning behind the result matters too.
5. The calculation and what you actually need to pay
Ask your accountant to distinguish the tax calculation from the amount payable through your HMRC account. Payments already made, amounts collected elsewhere and payments on account can affect the cash you need to set aside.
Payments on account are advance instalments towards the next tax bill. Where they apply, they are normally due on 31 January and 31 July. They can make the payment due different from the figure you expected from looking only at one year’s calculation.[3]
A useful payment explanation separates the relevant tax year, the amount, the deadline and any assumptions about payments HMRC has already received.
What should you see before approving your return?
Ask for the completed return, the tax calculation and an explanation of significant claims, assumptions or decisions. A covering letter or an in-product explanation can serve that purpose; the useful part is what it tells you.
ICAEW’s guidance says members should advise clients to review filings before submission, draw attention to judgemental positions and obtain evidence of approval. That supports a process in which you can ask questions before the return goes to HMRC.[1]
When reviewing, concentrate on things you are well placed to know:
- Are your details and the tax year correct?
- Are all relevant income sources and disposals included?
- Do the explanations match what happened?
- Are any documents or answers still missing?
- Do you understand the important claims and payment instructions?
You do not need to become a tax expert to question an unfamiliar figure. Ask for the explanation before approving.
Does accountant review remove your responsibility?
No. HMRC says you remain responsible for your tax affairs when using an agent and should review your return before signing it. It also advises against signing a blank return or sharing your HMRC sign-in details with an agent.[4]
That does not remove the accountant’s own professional responsibilities. ICAEW’s guidance makes a member preparing a filing responsible to the client for its accuracy based on the information supplied.[1] Your part is to provide complete information, answer questions honestly and flag anything that looks wrong.
What should you ask about support after filing?
Before instructing a service, establish who handles corrections, what happens if new information emerges, and whether HMRC correspondence or a formal enquiry is included in the fee. These can be different pieces of work.
A submission receipt confirms that a return was received; it does not mean HMRC has agreed every treatment or claim. HMRC describes Self Assessment as a system where returns can be processed first and examined later.[5]
For questions about cost and scope, see our guide to Self Assessment accountant fees. To compare named providers, use our service comparison.
How accountant preparation and review work with Record OS
Who prepares and reviews my Record OS tax return?
Our qualified UK accountants prepare, review and file your return. Depending on what it involves, one accountant or a small team may handle the work. You approve the return before we submit it to HMRC.
Does my free tax estimate include an accountant review?
No. The free estimate is automated and based on the documents and information you provide. Accountant work begins when you choose to proceed to paid filing. The estimate excludes payments on account, so it is not necessarily the amount payable to HMRC. Automatic estimates are not reliable for non-resident circumstances requiring SA109; however, paid filing for those circumstances is available.
What will I receive before approving my return?
Your prepared return and tax computation, together with explanations of significant decisions, reliefs, claims and assumptions. You can review these and ask questions before approving submission. We aim to make the reasoning understandable, including where the answer depends on information you have provided.
What if HMRC asks a question, or a correction is needed?
Responding to HMRC queries about a return we filed is included. Formal enquiries may need additional support agreed separately. We amend our own mistakes free of charge; amendments arising from new information may incur a separate charge. Amendments to returns filed elsewhere are charged at our normal fixed price, and earlier-year overpayment relief claims are outside our fixed filing prices.
Is ongoing accountant support included?
Yes. All filing tiers include year-round accountant access for payment advice, refund support, explanations of HMRC correspondence, help registering for or leaving Self Assessment, and proactive planning advice. See our Self Assessment service page for current prices, scope and how to start.
General information, not personalised tax advice. Check current HMRC guidance and your provider’s terms before acting.
Sources
- ICAEW: Helpsheet A: Submission of tax information and tax filings: responsibilities, supplied records, professional scepticism and approval. The practical questions in this article are editorial guidance, not a universal mandated checklist.
- HMRC: Tax-free allowances on property and trading income: eligibility and use of the trading allowance instead of actual expenses.
- HMRC: Payments on account: advance payments, timing and balancing payments.
- HMRC: How to choose a tax agent: responsibilities, qualifications, agreed services and reviewing a return.
- HMRC: SALF402: Enquiries into tax returns: processing and subsequent checks.
Record OS FAQ: founder-confirmed current service information, 22 October 2026. The illustrative example is not a client case study and contains no private client figures.
Related article
How much does a Self Assessment accountant cost?Do I need an accountant for Self Assessment?What software can I use to submit my UK personal tax return?Self Assessment payments on account explained, with a worked exampleDo I need to submit a Self Assessment tax return?How to register for Self Assessment for the first timeSelf Assessment deadlines: when to register, file and paySelf Assessment expenses: what can you claim?How to report rental income on your Self Assessment tax returnMaking Tax Digital for Income Tax: what changes for Self Assessment?